Kettlebell vs Dumbbell: Which to Buy First for Home Workouts

You have the budget for one weight and room for it in one corner of the living room, and the kettlebell vs dumbbell question stands between you and the order button. The short answer: buy one kettlebell first if you want full-body home workouts with swings and carries from a single weight. Buy adjustable dumbbells first if you want slow strength work on presses and curls, with small weight steps. Your goal and your floor space decide it, and so does how much technique you are willing to learn alone. You can settle it tonight.

Buy a kettlebell first if you want full-body workouts with one weight

A kettlebell's handle sits above the weight, so the load hangs below your hand. The bell can travel back between your legs in a swing, rest on the back of your forearm in the rack, sit against your chest by the horns for a goblet squat and circle your head in a halo. A dumbbell's handle runs through the middle of the weight, which suits pressing and curling and makes those other positions clumsy.

The result is coverage. One bell trains every pattern a home workout needs: the hinge with the Kettlebell Deadlift and later the swing, the squat with the Goblet Squat, the push with the Floor Press, the pull with the Single-Arm Row and the carry with the Suitcase Carry. Our full-body workout with one kettlebell puts all five patterns into one session.

Buy the first bell for your legs and hips, the strongest muscles you will train. Many women start with 8 to 12 kg (18 to 26 lb) and many men with 12 to 16 kg (26 to 35 lb). Pick a bell you can deadlift 10 times and goblet squat 8 times with a flat back and two reps left in reserve. Presses with that bell feel heavy at first, and the easier version of the Floor Press, pressing the bell with both hands, bridges that gap. Our guide on what kettlebell weight to start with has the full test.

One kettlebell covers more of a home workout than one dumbbell does

With one kettlebell you can do goblet squats, deadlifts, swings, rows, presses, floor presses and carries without changing weights. One dumbbell manages many of the same moves, and it handles the goblet squat well, held upright by one end. The swing is where it gets awkward: the handle runs through the weight and the hike between your thighs feels cramped. Dumbbell training is also built around pairs, so every step up in weight means buying two weights and paying twice. With one bell, you can do this session on day one.

Level: Beginner. Format: AMRAP 20 minutes (as many rounds as possible). Bell: one bell, many women 8 to 12 kg (18 to 26 lb), many men 12 to 16 kg (26 to 35 lb). Warm-up: about five minutes, ending with a ramp-up round of the workout at half the reps.

  • Kettlebell Deadlift x 8
  • Goblet Squat x 8
  • Single-Arm Row x 6 per side
  • Floor Press x 6 per side
  • Suitcase March x 20 steps per side

Rest as soon as a rep looks worse than your first one. Stop an exercise on sharp pain in a joint, or when you are so short of breath you cannot say a short sentence, and rest until your breathing settles. If you feel dizzy, nauseous or unwell, stop the workout, sit down and check with a doctor before you train again. Chest pain, pain that spreads to your arm, jaw or back, sudden or severe shortness of breath, a sudden severe headache or fainting during exercise mean you stop at once and get medical help straight away. Row the bell to your hip. On the Goblet Squat, hold the bell against your chest with your elbows inside your knees, and go only as deep as your back stays flat. On the Floor Press, touch your elbow down softly, and after the last rep lower the bell to your chest and roll to your side before you put it down. If pressing is too heavy, use both hands for 8 reps. On the Suitcase March, stay tall with your shoulders level, then set the bell down with bent knees and switch hands. Your rounds plus extra reps are next week's target. Our 20-minute kettlebell workout builds on this session.

Buy dumbbells first if you want small weight steps for presses, curls and slow strength work

Dumbbells win on increments. Most kettlebells come in 4 kg (9 lb) steps: 8, 12, 16 kg and up. For a deadlift that jump is manageable. For a one-arm press it is large: going from an 8 kg bell to a 12 kg bell adds half the weight at once, and the press tends to stall between the two. Adjustable dumbbell sets move in steps of 1 to 2.5 kg (2 to 5.5 lb), so a press or a curl gets heavier a little at a time. For slow strength work, where you add load every week or two, those small steps keep you moving.

The pair is the second edge. With a dumbbell in each hand, both sides work at once under the same load: presses on the floor, rows, lunges with the weights at your sides. One kettlebell trains most presses and rows one side at a time, so the same work takes two sets.

The wrist is the third. A dumbbell's weight sits in line with your hand, so your wrist stays neutral and nothing rests on your forearm. A kettlebell in the rack rests on the back of your forearm, and finding the spot where it sits comfortably takes practice.

Both tools build strength and muscle when the load or the reps go up over weeks, and the research gives neither a clear edge. Choose by the work you want to do.

Count the space, the noise and the price before you order

A kettlebell takes almost no storage: it sits in a corner on a footprint the size of a shoe box. Training with it takes more room. For swings, clear 2 meters in front of you and 1 meter to each side, keep children and pets out of that space, and dry your hands before you grip the handle. Deadlifts, squats, rows and floor presses fit on a patch the size of a yoga mat, so without room for a swing lane one bell still covers the hinge, squat, press, row and carry.

Fixed dumbbell pairs need a rack or a row along the wall, which claims a corner. An adjustable set needs a small patch of floor for its stand and asks for setting time between exercises. In an AMRAP the clock keeps running while you change the weight. Check the lock before every set, on adjustable dumbbells and adjustable kettlebells alike, and follow the maker's rating for swinging: if the maker does not rate it for swings, keep it for slow lifts.

Iron meeting the floor sounds the same whatever its shape. Set your weight down with bent knees on a mat or rug, at the end of every set and on every rep that ends on the floor.

One cast-iron kettlebell is the smallest outlay for a first weight. A pair of fixed dumbbells at the same weight per hand costs about twice as much, because you buy two. An adjustable dumbbell set costs the most upfront and replaces a rack of fixed pairs, so it pays off once you would otherwise buy several pairs.

Beginners learn dumbbell moves faster, and the kettlebell swing comes after the deadlift

A dumbbell press or row feels familiar on the first rep, because the weight sits in your hand where you expect it. The kettlebell swing and the clean are skills. In a swing your hips snap forward and send the bell up while your arms hang like ropes. The bell floats to chest height, no higher, and at the top you stand tall like a plank. The common mistake is squatting the swing: the knees bend deep and the bell travels low, down by the knees. It comes from swinging before the hinge is learned. The clean comes later still: it is an Intermediate exercise in the app, learned once the two-hand swing is solid.

Learn the lifts in order. The Kettlebell Deadlift comes first: bell between your feet, hips back with your shins close to vertical, back flat, then push the floor away and stand tall. If your knees bend deep, you are squatting the lift: push your hips back further. The Goblet Squat follows. Once ten deadlifts look the same from the first rep to the last, add the Dead-Stop Swing. Set the bell on the floor a little in front of you, in your clear swing lane, hike it back high between your thighs, swing it once and park it on the floor again with a flat back. Reset and breathe before the next rep. When every Dead-Stop Swing in a set of 10 looks the same, try a few swings in a row without parking the bell, then park it with a flat back. Build those runs up to the app's marker for Intermediate, 20 good swings without a break. The Two-Hand Swing, where the bell keeps moving from rep to rep, starts at that level.

Stop a swing when your lower back hurts or rounds, when you feel a sharp pain in the back of a leg, or when the swing pulls you forward. Let it die down and park the bell softly in front of you. If you have any doubt about your health, check with a doctor before you start.

Living Room Athlete is an Android app for structured home workouts with kettlebells, body weight and an optional fixed pull-up bar. It has over 2,000 workouts, built on professional strength and conditioning principles. Every one of its exercises comes with a written cue, two form cues, a common mistake and a "stop if" line, and a Beginner gets the Dead-Stop Swing until they move up to Intermediate.

Use both once your training is regular, with the kettlebell for the hinge and dumbbells for presses

After a few months of regular sessions, and with room and budget to spare, a mixed setup works well. The first bell stays your bell for deadlifts, goblet squats and swings. The second purchase is often for presses: a lighter kettlebell, 4 kg below the first if your first bell is 12 kg or heavier, or a light pair of dumbbells for presses and curls. If you started with 8 kg, the second buy is usually a heavier bell for the lower body, and the 8 kg becomes your press bell. Our guide on which kettlebell to buy helps you choose the bell itself.

Living Room Athlete is built for kettlebells, body weight and an optional fixed pull-up bar, and it has no dumbbell exercises. With a pair of dumbbells, you plan those presses and curls yourself, after the app's workout or on a separate day.

The kettlebell vs dumbbell verdict, situation by situation:

  • One purchase, a small room, full-body workouts with swings and carries: one kettlebell.
  • Presses, curls and slow strength work in small steps, no interest in swings: adjustable dumbbells.
  • Three sessions a week for months, with room and budget for more: a bell for the lower body plus a lighter bell or a light pair of dumbbells for presses.

When your first bell arrives, enter it in Living Room Athlete: each day's workout is matched to that bell and your level, with the reps adjusted for training with one bell.

Questions people ask

Is a kettlebell or a dumbbell better for beginners?

Dumbbell moves are quicker to learn, because the weight sits in your hand where you expect it. A kettlebell gives you more full-body options from one weight once you have learned the hip hinge. Start the bell with the Kettlebell Deadlift and the Dead-Stop Swing, and add the two-hand swing at the Intermediate level.

If the weight is the same, is a kettlebell harder than a dumbbell?

In swings, presses and carries the load of a kettlebell sits further from your hand, so the same weight takes more control. In deadlifts and goblet squats the two feel much the same. In presses, many people find a kettlebell feels heavier than a dumbbell of the same weight.

Can a kettlebell replace dumbbells at home?

For most home workouts, yes. One or two bells cover the hinge, squat, press, row and carry. Dumbbells keep an edge for small weight steps on presses and for paired work, with both arms pressing at once.

Should I buy one kettlebell or a pair of dumbbells?

Buy one kettlebell if you want full-body strength and conditioning from a single weight in a small space. Buy a pair of light dumbbells, or an adjustable set, if presses and arm work are your priority. Many home trainees end up with a bell for the lower body and a lighter bell or a light pair of dumbbells for presses.

General fitness information. If you have any doubt about your health, check with a doctor first. Read our guide to training safely at home before you start.

Kettlebell workouts for your living room

Over 2,000 workouts, built on professional strength and conditioning principles.

Free download with 5 free sessions, no card needed.

Android Get it on Google Play